If a storm has damaged your roof, do four things in this order: get everyone safe, stop more water from getting in, photograph everything, and call your insurer before you commission permanent repairs. Then have the roof inspected by a licensed local roofer so you know whether you are looking at a repair or a replacement. At Revive Exteriors (Michigan Lic. #262500123, revivemihome.com), we inspect roofs across Northern Michigan at no charge, and the rest of this guide shows you what to look for and what to expect.
TL;DR
- Safety first: stay off the roof, stay out of any building a fallen tree has opened up, and look from the ground.
- Cover holes with a tarp or plywood, keep every receipt, and wait on permanent repairs until your insurer has been told.
- Take dated photos and video of the roof, attic, ceilings and yard before anything is moved.
- Damage you cannot see from the ground is common, so a professional inspection is worth booking even if nothing drips.
- Repair or replace depends on roof age, how much of the roof is hurt, and whether the damage is functional or only cosmetic.
Table of Contents
- The first hours: safety and stopping water
- Do not make permanent repairs yet
- What storm damage looks like
- Document everything before you touch it
- Filing a claim: deductible, coverage type and timing
- Repair or replace?
- Why a professional inspection comes next
- What the work looks like in Northern Michigan
- Perspective
- Get your roof looked at
- FAQ
- Sources
The first hours: safety and stopping water
The NAIC Post-Disaster Claims Guide, published by the association of state insurance regulators, puts safety for you and your family first. Only after that does it tell you to secure the home to prevent more damage or theft.
In practice:
- Do not climb onto the roof. Wet shingles, ice, debris and weakened decking make a damaged roof dangerous to walk on. Inspect from the ground, ideally with binoculars.
- If a tree is on the house or part of the roof has blown open, stay out of the affected rooms. The National Insurance Restoration Council says to stay out of the building until a contractor has checked it for structural damage.
- Turn to the inside. If water is coming through a ceiling, move belongings, put a bucket under the drip, and if a ceiling is bulging with water, poke a small hole in a safe spot to let it drain only if you can do so from a safe position. Keep the area clear of anyone standing beneath it.
- Cover openings. The NAIC guide says to cover roof holes with a tarp and to make essential repairs using plywood, tarp, canvas or other waterproof materials while keeping the receipts.
A tarp is a stopgap, and in Northern Michigan it has to survive wind, snow load and freezing temperatures. A tarp that flaps loose can tear more shingles. Securing one on a steep or icy roof is exactly the work that sends homeowners to the emergency room, so if the opening is above the reach of a ladder from the ground, call a roofer rather than going up yourself.
Do not make permanent repairs yet
Temporary repairs to prevent further damage are expected. Permanent ones are different. The NAIC guide says not to make permanent repairs before talking with your insurer. The Texas Department of Insurance gives the same advice: make temporary repairs, save receipts, and wait for the adjuster before permanent work. Michigan’s rules are set by Michigan, so read your own policy for the details, but the principle is common: the insurer should see the damage before it disappears under new shingles.
That does not mean waiting to get the roof assessed. A contractor’s inspection and the insurer’s inspection are separate steps, and the first can happen quickly.
What storm damage looks like
Some damage is obvious, some is not. Owens Corning’s checklist lists the visible signs: dented, torn, curled or missing shingles, dents on gutters and vents, and cracked or broken windows. From the ground, the National Insurance Restoration Council adds displaced metal around the chimney, damaged exhaust pipes, and trouble at valleys, edges and the points where the roof meets a wall.
Wind
High winds can tear shingles off entirely and expose the underlayment, the roof deck or the waterproofing. In weaker storms, gusts can lift and curl shingles and break the seal that makes the overlap watertight, leaving the roof vulnerable to wind-driven rain. A roof can look nearly normal from the street and still have lost that seal.
Hail
Check your gutters and downspout outlets. Excess shingle granules there may have been knocked loose by hail. Those granules protect the asphalt coating from ultraviolet light, so losing them shortens the life of the roof.

Insurers and adjusters distinguish functional damage from cosmetic damage. According to one adjuster-focused guide, functional hail damage includes bruising that fractures the shingle mat, granule loss that exposes the mat, cracks radiating from an impact, missing tabs and broken seal strips, while scuffing, algae streaks and surface dimples without mat fracture are treated as cosmetic. Knowing the difference helps you read an estimate.
Inside the house
Go into the attic with a flashlight. Look for daylight where there should be none, damp insulation, dark stains on the underside of the roof deck and water spots on ceilings. Owens Corning notes that wind and hail can cause hidden leaks even when the roof looks fine from outside. A leak that is not found now tends to show up months later as mold, rotted decking or a stained ceiling, long after the claim window may have narrowed.
Document everything before you touch it
This is the step that most affects what you are paid. Take photos and video of:
- The roof surface, from every safe angle on the ground, plus close-ups of anything you can see.
- Gutters, vents, siding, windows and fences. Storms rarely hit only the roof.
- Fallen limbs or debris, before they are moved.
- The attic, ceilings and walls inside, including water stains.
- Any temporary repair you make, and the receipts for materials.
GAF’s insurance guide recommends receipts, photos and a home inventory, and AAA advises dated photos taken before work begins. One adjuster-focused guide suggests photographing damage within 72 hours and using the NOAA Storm Events Database to confirm the storm date and county. Write down the date and time of the storm and what you heard and saw.
The Texas Department of Insurance also advises not throwing anything away until the adjuster says you may, and keeping a running list of repairs.
Filing a claim: deductible, coverage type and timing
Check your deductible first
The NAIC guide says to check your deductible before reporting. If only a few shingles are damaged, paying out of pocket may cost less than filing, but you may not see all the damage, so an inspection can help you decide. Wind and hail deductibles can also differ from your standard deductible, as the Texas Department of Insurance points out. Read the declarations page of your policy for the figure.
Replacement cost versus actual cash value
This distinction decides how much money you receive:
| Coverage type | What it pays | Why it matters for an older roof |
|---|---|---|
| Replacement cost | Up to the full cost of repair at current prices | Often paid in two checks: a first partial payment, then the rest after repairs begin |
| Actual cash value | Replacement cost minus depreciation for age and wear | Pays less if the roof is older or worn |
The two-check structure and the difference between the coverage types come from the Texas Department of Insurance. Ohio’s insurance department adds that many policies require repairs within a set period, such as 180 days from the date of loss, after which payment may drop to actual cash value. Your own policy states its own time limit.
What is and is not covered
AAA explains that many policies cover sudden, accidental damage from events like hail or falling trees, while damage from age, neglect or wear and tear is typically not covered. That is why documentation of the storm date matters: it separates a storm loss from an old roof wearing out.
Deadlines
Policies set their own deadlines. One industry guide says most homeowner policies require roof claims within one year of the storm, with some states allowing two and some carriers shortening it to six months. Call your insurer promptly and ask for the filing deadline in writing.
The adjuster’s visit
The adjuster’s job is to inspect and document the damage. Whether the damage is covered is decided by the insurer. The Texas Windstorm Insurance Association says the adjuster will schedule an inspection with you or your representative, and you can have your contractor present. Adjusters most often walk the roof, though drones and ladder assists are also used. Treat on-site comments as impressions, not a coverage decision. Stick to facts: when the storm hit, what you saw, what you photographed.
Repair or replace?
Three things drive the answer: the age of the roof, how widespread the damage is, and whether the damage is functional.
Age. AAA says most asphalt shingle roofs last about 20 years. Its example: a 12-year-old roof with damage limited to one area may be more cost-effective to repair, while a 19-year-old roof damaged in multiple spots may be better replaced.
Extent. AAA also notes that experts often suggest replacement makes more financial sense once more than 20% to 25% of the roof is damaged. Treat that as a cost rule of thumb. The same guidance observes that repeated repairs on a heavily damaged or aging roof can add up to more than a replacement.

Type of damage. Sagging, widespread granule loss, interior leaks in several spots or creased and lifted shingles across a whole slope point toward replacement. A handful of missing shingles on a young roof points toward repair.
Local rules in Northern Michigan
You may hear of a “25% rule” requiring a whole roof to be brought up to code once a quarter of it is replaced. That provision exists in some codes, such as Florida’s, but the repair-versus-replace figure above is a cost guideline and not a Michigan code requirement. Permit rules vary by city and township, so confirm with your local building department before work starts. The City of Alpena, for instance, posts its building permit forms and adopted codes online. A licensed contractor will know the local process.
Matching and partial roofs
If the damage covers one slope and your shingles are discontinued or weathered, a patch may not look like the rest of the roof. Michigan has no statute or regulation requiring insurers to match undamaged roofing, and a federal court in Michigan held in 2012 that a common policy provision does not require matching. So ask your insurer how it treats matching before you decide how much to repair.
Why a professional inspection comes next
Most of what makes a storm damaged roof costly is what you cannot see: lifted seals, bruised mats, wet decking and flashing pulled loose. A ground-level look will not catch it, and neither will a quick glance from a ladder. A trained inspector walks the roof, checks the decking and the attic, and gives you a written picture of what is functional damage and what is wear.
We offer complimentary inspections, and our guide to what a free roof inspection involves explains what to expect and how to tell a thorough one from a sales pitch. If you are unsure about timing, our page on when to get a roof inspection covers it. If the roof is aging, see the signs you need a new roof.
What the work looks like in Northern Michigan
Our climate is hard on roofs: heavy snow load, freeze-thaw cycles and lake-effect wind. Whichever way your inspection comes out, the repair has to be built for that. Our roof repair service covers leaks and storm damage, and when replacement is the answer we install asphalt and metal roofing with manufacturer-certified products. You can see a roof replacement in progress, a winter replacement and a finished roof to get a sense of the process.
If the storm also hit gutters, siding or windows, it is worth having the whole exterior checked at once. Storm winds that lift shingles often dent gutters and crack window glass too, and it is simpler to handle everything in a single project with a single point of contact. We assign dedicated project management to each job.
Perspective
After a storm, most homeowners are juggling an insurer, a phone full of photos and a ceiling stain, and the temptation is to pick whoever answers first. We would rather you slow down on the decision and speed up on the protection: tarp it, photograph it, report it, then get a clear picture of the roof.
What we care about is that the roof you end up with is built for Northern Michigan. Our materials are engineered for local weather, our pricing is transparent and fair, and every project has a dedicated project manager so you know who to call. We are locally owned, hold an A+ rating from the BBB, and stand behind the work with a satisfaction promise.
A storm is also a natural moment to ask what your roof needs for the next twenty years. Sometimes that is a repair. Sometimes it is a full replacement with better materials, and we will tell you which one the roof actually calls for.
Jack
Get your roof looked at
If a storm has hit your home in Traverse City, Petoskey, Alpena, Gaylord, Cadillac, Charlevoix or elsewhere in Northern Michigan, Revive Exteriors can inspect the roof at no charge and give you a clear quote for repair or replacement. Our work is done under Michigan Lic. #262500123. Start at our roofing page or roof replacement page, visit revivemihome.com, or call (866) 466-3351.

FAQ
Can I claim wind damage on my roof?
Usually yes, if your policy covers wind, since many policies cover sudden damage from events like storms and falling trees. Damage from age or wear is typically excluded. Photograph the damage, review your deductible and call your insurer promptly, before permanent repairs begin.
What should I do if my roof leaks during a storm?
Get people away from the affected area, move belongings, and catch the water with buckets. Once conditions are safe, cover the opening with a tarp or plywood from the ground or a stable ladder position, and keep the receipts. Do not climb onto a wet or icy roof. A roofer can handle the exterior repair.
Should I replace the roof or repair it?
It depends on age and extent. Asphalt shingles last about 20 years, and replacement often makes sense once more than 20% to 25% of the roof is damaged. A young roof with one damaged area is usually a repair. An inspection tells you which applies to yours.
Do I need a permit to replace storm damaged roofing in Michigan?
Rules differ by city and township. Minor repairs like patching a few shingles often need no permit, while larger roofing work often does. Check with your local building department before starting.
Sources
- NAIC Post-Disaster Claims Guide
- Owens Corning: Roof Storm Damage Checklist
- National Insurance Restoration Council: Storm Damage Inspection
- The Roofing Brief: How Much Hail Damage Replaces a Roof?
- GAF: Guide to Roof Damage Insurance Claims
- Texas Department of Insurance: Help after a storm
- Texas Department of Insurance: Insurance and your roof
- Ohio Department of Insurance: Roof Insurance, Repair and Replacement
- AAA: Roof Repair or Replace
- TWIA Claims Webinar
- RoofingInsurance.com: The 25% Rule Explained
- City of Alpena: Forms and Permits
- University of Pennsylvania insurance matching memo
Recommended
- Roof Repair in Traverse City, MI: Leaks & Storm Damage
- Asphalt shingle roof that may need replacement
- Roof Replacement in Traverse City & Cadillac, MI
- Roof Replacement Timeline: What to Expect in Northern Michigan
Revive Exteriors | (866) 466-3351 | revivemihome.com | Michigan Lic. #262500123
